Hi everyone! Well, it’s official. It’s Tuesday afternoon, and I’m sitting in my living room, which once again looks just like my living room. But only a few days ago, it was DECKED in iridescent tinsel curtains, countless neon balloons, disco balls, red carpets, taffeta fabrics, and so much more. It WAS Mayhem High’s gymnasium! And if you’re curious as to why, well, because it was prom, of course! And not just any prom. A totally RAD 80’s prom gone BAD! That’s right, we hosted our second murder mystery party with the most ~tubular~ theme. I am so giddy to jump into the details with you and rehash all the fun that we had, so let’s jump into it!

This is my second year using The Night of Mystery party kits, so while I cannot speak to a different brand, I feel confident recommending this company to you! The game kits are very well planned and detailed. They come with a host guide, game materials, and thoughtful extras, including party inspiration and printables you can use as instant decorations.
The games can be purchased and played in different group sizes; I have used the 20+ player game both times. There is also the option to choose the version of the game you’d like to play: Adult, Adult Clean, LGBTQ Female or Male, and Teen. Additionally, you have the ability to purchase either an in-person game or a virtual version. We have played the “Adult In-Person” version each time, and while it’s definitely for adults, there wasn’t any material that made my guests uncomfortable or required anyone to do anything too risqué. The NoM website does a wonderful job of explaining how the game works and even allows you to download sample hosting guides before you purchase. (This is not sponsored in any way! Just sharing what has worked for me!)

While the kit comes with printable snail mail invitations and email invitations, I prefer to create my own via Paperless Post. You definitely want to be able to collect a solid headcount before you begin assigning characters. I also love using PP because, with their fun designs, you can already set the tone for how you want your party to feel!
When assigning the characters, the game recommends which characters would be beneficial for the host to play, which characters must be played, and which characters can be eliminated should someone need to cancel. Know that it’s a lot of reading, but it really helps when setting up the game!
Something that I do that I feel ups the ante and encourages my guests to embrace coming in full-on character is sending ALL of my correspondence in the tone of my character. I choose to email each guest their character packet along with a note in my character’s tone. Any information that I need to send out, such as reminders, also comes in the tone of my character. I even write a farewell/thank-you email and gab about and touch on what each player brought to the game. If you want your friends to come and be fully committed, I truly feel that this helps!

Assembling the game takes clever organization, but don’t be alarmed! It comes with checklists aplenty. The game works in two parts: Part A (before the murder) and Part B (after the murder). Each guest has an A and a B envelope with objectives for them to follow throughout each part of the game. I have all of the A envelopes prepped, organized, and ready to hand out as soon as guests arrive, which makes the start of the night feel much smoother. I keep the B envelopes tucked away until after the murder has taken place, so no one gets ahead of the game!
This year, I also opted to hand-make a clever “Most Likely To” name tag badge for each guest. Totally not required, but I felt like it added to the fun and helped everyone settle into their characters right away!


And now for the fun part: it’s time to transform and decorate! Once your materials are prepped and characters are accounted for, I let my creativity flow! Creating a game environment only adds to the element of this type of party. So if I was asking my friends to come in ’80s glam, I wanted them to walk into a true, cheesy ’80s prom!
I slid my coffee table to the front of my living room to create a “stage” and dance floor. I used this red carpet down my front entryway and into the home, because what’s an ’80s prom without a tacky, glittery red carpet? I purchased various colors of tinsel curtains and covered every window! I used this disco ball set to hang throughout the space, along with these lights and these disco balls, to create that perfect glittering effect! I made the banners on Canva and had them printed same-day at Walgreens, a party trick I will be keeping in my pocket for events to come!
I reached out to this Etsy shop, and she custom-made our prom court sashes. They were AMAZING! I set up the sashes alongside the Prom King and Queen crowns and the awards for the night. The kit comes with awards for Best Dressed, Most Wealth, Best Actor, and Super Sleuth. I used these mini disco balls as the prizes, and they were perfect!
While researching and brainstorming ideas on Pinterest, I came across this blog post and just knew I wanted to recreate her yearbook Polaroid idea! But, ah, we ran out of film mid-party. Note to self: don’t let that happen again!
The rest of the party decorations came together with the assistance of two very sweet girlfriends! We used this photo arch, which I am excited to use for future parties because it assembled and disassembled so easily, to create that true awkward prom photo moment. We added neon balloons, disco balloons, 1986 balloons, and more tinsel, and we were there!
For the tables, my boys helped me splatter-paint two white tablecloths I picked up from Target, which was fun for them and great for our theme! I found metallic, taffeta-inspired fabric at Michaels, which made for an affordable and perfectly on-theme table runner and tablecloth.









Regarding food and drinks, I wanted to keep the menu fairly simple and easy to munch on all night long. I decided on assorted boxes of pizza from trusty Domino’s. I wanted to leave the pizza boxes on the set table because I felt like it gave that, “Here, we ordered boxes of pizza with our prom budget” vibe. You feel me, right? Pizza was absolutely the right move! It allowed everyone to grab a slice when they needed a little something extra to go with all the (spiked!) punch. I also set up a small sweet & salty section featuring chocolate, sour candy, chips, and cookies! Again, all very easy to quickly grab with your fingers and keep playing.
For drinks, I created three signature punches (recipes below!) and served each one in these punch bowls. As much as I would have loved to invest in beautiful punch bowls, I’m just not sure when I would truly use them again, so these were inexpensive and perfect for the night! I created little signs on Canva and folded each one in front of its bowl.
In addition, we had bottles of champagne, wine, and plenty of assorted alcoholic and nonalcoholic canned drinks for anyone to grab. While the punch bowls were obviously a hit, the real stars were these fantastic color-changing cups that Chrissy from Kool Cups created for me! They were so much fun! They also made for a very fun keepsake for guests! 😉







And that, my friends, was Mayhem High Prom! Truly, this was one of those nights that reminded me exactly why I love hosting these kinds of parties so much. The costumes, the characters, the ridiculous details, the laughter, the commitment from our friends… all of it made the night feel so incredibly fun and memorable. If you’re thinking about hosting your own murder mystery party, I hope this gives you the little push to just go for it! It does take some planning, but watching everyone walk through the door fully committed to the theme makes every bit of it worth it.
I’ve linked as many of the items I used throughout this post as I could, and you can also find even more of the party supplies, decorations, and extras I used on my Amazon storefront. Now I just have one question: what theme should we do next?!





